Sources checked November 12, 2026 · See sources and assumptions

First, make sure you are comparing the same thing#
Find the period start and end dates on each stub. A two-week paycheque and a twice-monthly paycheque cover different schedules. A partial first pay period is another easy mismatch. Our pay-schedule guide explains the difference.
Next, separate three numbers: your salary or hourly rate, the earnings on this paystub, and the net amount paid. CRA’s paystub explanation distinguishes earnings before deductions from take-home pay. Comparing only the bank deposits leaves out the reason for the difference.
Look for a separate reimbursement, a second deposit or a split between accounts. A $1,700 deposit plus $200 sent to another account is $1,900 of pay, not $1,700.
Read down the stub in this order#
| Line to compare | Question to ask |
|---|---|
| Period dates and paid hours | Did the periods cover the same length of time and the same hours? |
| Cash earnings | Did overtime, unpaid time, vacation pay, a bonus or a correction change? |
| Income tax | Was the amount withheld different, even if base earnings stayed the same? |
| CPP / QPP and EI / QPIP | Did a contribution start, stop, reach a maximum or move to another line? |
| Pension, benefits and other deductions | Did enrolment, a contribution choice, dues or a catch-up deduction change? |
| Other cash additions | Was an expense reimbursement included on only one paystub? |
Copy employee amounts only. An employer pension contribution shown for information does not necessarily come off your pay. Likewise, a taxable non-cash benefit can affect payroll calculations without being cash you receive. Ask payroll how an unfamiliar line is treated before including it in a cash reconciliation.
Why CPP and EI can make late-year and January pay look different#
For a continuing employee, CRA says the employer stops deducting CPP contributions and EI premiums once the applicable annual maximum has been reached in that employment. Those limits are annual, so reaching one can change a later paycheque; a new year begins a new contribution period. Not everyone reaches a maximum.
CPP also has a second additional contribution, CPP2, on earnings in a separate band. Do not assume that one CPP line falling means every pension contribution has ended. Quebec payroll uses QPP and may include QPIP; copy the actual lines instead of substituting CPP figures.
A new employer generally starts its own CPP and EI deductions without counting what the previous employer withheld. CRA explains that employee overpayments may be reconciled when filing a tax return. That can help explain a restarted deduction after a job change; it does not establish that your particular stub is wrong.
A $25 change, explained line by line#
Made-up paystubs, not calculated tax rates. Cash earnings stay at $2,500, CPP/QPP at $145 and EI/QPIP at $40 in both periods. This explains the arithmetic, not why deductions changed.
Try these amounts in the paycheque comparison calculator. If the result doesn’t match your net pay, look for an omitted line, a non-cash item or a correction before treating it as a payroll error.
A useful question to send payroll#
Be specific about the changed line. For example: “My cash earnings are the same for these two periods, but the income-tax deduction fell by $65 and the pension deduction rose by $40. Can you explain what changed and whether it will continue next pay?”
Use your employer’s normal secure payroll channel if they need the stubs. You do not need to upload them here: our calculator asks only for amounts and does the comparison on your device.
Until you know whether a higher deposit will repeat, avoid building a new monthly commitment around it. Use the budget-until-payday planner with the next confirmed deposit.
Common questions
Does a smaller paycheque always mean my taxes went up?
No. Compare cash earnings, each deduction, reimbursements and the pay-period dates. A benefit or pension change can affect the deposit without a change in salary.
Why could my first January paycheque be smaller?
Annual CPP and EI deductions can restart after a maximum was reached in the previous year. Other payroll changes can happen too, so compare the actual lines rather than assuming one cause.
Will the calculator tell me whether my employer deducted the right tax?
No. It reconciles the numbers you enter and shows their effect on net pay. It does not apply payroll tax tables or determine a refund.
Sources and notes
Published by The Paycheque. Sources checked . Examples are illustrative. Check your provider’s agreement or employer’s pay schedule for your own terms.

