Sources checked November 16, 2026 · See sources and assumptions

What $5 looks like over three months#
Interest is extra. This example assumes no monthly waiver and no daily cap changing the number of charges. These are not quotes or recommendations to borrow more often.
The fee-only break-even point here is three chargeable uses: $15 ÷ $5. If the rate or balance differs between the options, include those differences before deciding. Put your agreement’s fee and charge counts into our overdraft calculator.
“Per use” depends on the bank#
| Plan detail | TD | Scotiabank |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly protection fee | $5, subject to account terms | $5 even if unused; does not apply to Quebec residents |
| Pay-per-use fee | $5 per transaction, maximum $5 per day | $5 when overdraft is created or increased |
| Published annual interest | 21% | 21% |
| Pay-per-use in Quebec | Not available | Not available |
These examples are here to show why counting rules matter, not to rank banks. Confirm the current account package, approved limit, waivers and repayment conditions. A published fee is not confirmation that you qualify.
Count the next few billing periods#
- Mark the charged months. Use billing periods from the agreement, not an assumed 30-day month. A short overdraft can cross a billing boundary.
- Count chargeable uses. Apply any daily cap and the bank’s definition of a new or increased overdraft.
- Add the interest. Enter each consecutive balance period once. Read how overdraft interest works for an example.
- Include a new account cost. If you would switch to a paid account for the benefit, include its additional price. Keep an existing account fee visible in your budget even if it would be paid either way.
Do not choose a recurring charge based only on your busiest month. Try a quiet month as well. A future usage estimate is a scenario, not a prediction.
Could something else cover the timing gap?#
Before changing a borrowing plan, check whether moving a bill date would solve the mismatch. A biller has to agree to the change; use our bill-date planner to test it first.
If comparing an app with overdraft, include every required fee and subscription. Compare an overdraft with a cash advance, then check delivery and next-payday repayments separately.
Common questions
Is monthly overdraft always cheaper?
No. It depends on how many months are charged, the number of billable uses, the interest rates and any waivers. In the example, one chargeable use over three charged months favours pay-per-use.
Does paying the balance back cancel the monthly fee?
Not necessarily. Repaying an overdraft and cancelling or changing a protection plan are different actions. Ask the bank what remains active and whether changing it affects future payments.
Can I count every purchase as a pay-per-use charge?
Use your bank’s rule. A daily cap or a rule tied to creating or increasing an overdraft can make the number of charges different from the number of purchases.
Sources and notes
Published by The Paycheque. Sources checked . Examples are illustrative. Check your provider’s agreement or employer’s pay schedule for your own terms.

